Seven Arbitrarily Chosen Things You’re Missing Out On If You’ve Been Operating Under the Mistaken Belief that JRPGs are “Dead”

It seems that every time we get a new Dragon Quest, Final Fantasy or Persona release, we have the same old “we’re having a JRPG renaissance!” discussion.

Well, dear reader, with my coverage of Death End Re;Quest on the horizon at the time of writing and plenty more RPGs in our shared futures, I’m here to remind you that RPGs have been alive and well ever since what people think of as their “golden age” — the SNES and PS1 eras. This will not be a shock to some of you reading this, of course, but I’m sure there are quite a few people out there who have passed up some wonderful experiences for one reason or another.

So with that in mind, I thought I’d do a list of seven arbitrarily chosen things that you might have missed out on if you’ve been operating under the grossly mistaken assumption that the role-playing game genre has somehow been “dead” despite plenty of evidence to the contrary. Here we go!

Colourful, memorable characters

Arguably the defining feature of Japanese and Japanese-style RPGs for many, the presence of heavily stylised, memorable characters provides an important means for a game to stick in your mind well after the credits have rolled. You spend a lot of time with the core cast in a role-playing game, and if the developers have done their job properly, you’ll feel sad saying goodbye to them at the end of the adventure.

One of my favourite things about this aspect of the games we’re talking about here is describing the characters out of context, because it’s often rather amusing. Can you name the games these ensemble casts are from?

  • An unjustly convicted juvenile delinquent, a quarter-American Japanese resident who lived for a while in Finland, a ginger-haired information technology genius with severe social anxiety, a former member of the track team, the School Council president, a teenage artist, the daughter of a ruthless but successful businessman and some cat thing
  • A piece of never-released Sega hardware, the Sega Game Gear, the Sony PlayStation 3, the PSP, the Xbox 360, the Nintendo Wii, the Nintendo DS, the developer of their own game and the publisher of their own game
  • A gay vampire demon and her domestically-impaired girlfriend
  • A half-Russian, half Japanese guy who can turn into monsters, a female lieutenant in the German army, an aromatherapist, a white wolf, Gepetto from Pinocchio, Princess Anastasia Romanov and a vampire wrestler

Interesting, imaginative or unconventional settings

This is by no means exclusive to Japanese games, of course, but today’s Western games very much tend to favour the “realistic” side of things, while the JRPGs we’ve had the opportunity to enjoy over the years tend to throw plausibility out of the window and then absolutely run with their concepts, however ridiculous they might seem.

What we end up with in the process is some extremely well-realised settings that, while physically impossible in many cases, nonetheless draw you into the experience and help you feel like you’re part of those characters’ world.

How well do you know your RPG settings? Test yourself! Which game unfolded in each of these settings?

  • A post-apocalyptic world in which humanity has retreated to a single large city as their last bastion of defense against the “Blare”, where idols bring the people hope against hope
  • On, in and around a tower that stretches up into the heavens, far above the churning, fatal surface of the planet
  • On the backs and inside the bodies of mighty Titans who float majestically through the skies, the perpetual ocean of clouds obscuring the truth of the planet’s surface far beneath
  • On an artificial clockwork planet that occasionally needs “winding up” to keep turning

Cool battle mechanics that are unique to video games

Western RPGs have somewhat moved away from attempting to be strict adaptations of tabletop rulesets these days, but a lot of them still tend to be somewhat grounded in reality, or at least an interpretation of reality that includes magic or magic-like abilities, anyway.

In your average modern JRPG, meanwhile, once again, plausibility tends to go right out of the window in the name of creating a fun and satisfying experience that works well as a game.

How well do you know your battle systems?

  • Throw a bomb, follow it up with an attack from an ally, follow it up with another ally’s attack, throw a more powerful version of that bomb, admire a joint attack from both your allies, then finally fling a nuclear-powered variant of your original bomb that would probably take out half the planet if we were paying any attention to physics whatsoever
  • Burst into song, engage harmonics, unleash a combo attack between all five characters that deals multiple millions of points of damage in total, ideally “overkilling” the enemy by their original maximum HP value for additional rewards and bonuses
  • Call upon your friends during boss battles to perform motivational speeches, do their makeup, smash a tennis ball into your foe’s face, bandage your boo-boos and finally kick the world’s most dangerous empty drinks can right into the boss’ balls
  • Hit this thing and all the squares on the floor will turn a different colour, which might be a good thing but might also make a real mess of whatever strategy you were planning to make use of!

A soundtrack that remembers it’s from a video game, not a movie

Don’t get me wrong — there’s nothing wrong with the movie-inspired approach to video game soundtracks, and in fact I vividly recall in the late ’90s or so wishing beyond hope that games would “move on” from synthesised sound and into real instruments, fully orchestrated arrangements and a more movie-like feel.

However, what I didn’t count on in those younger days is that music for movies and games fulfil two very different purposes, and while there’s sometimes some overlap, they don’t always mesh. Speaking broadly, movie music complements a specific event or moment in time, while game music is more constant and repetitive, as much complementing characters, situations and even mechanics as it does specific, one-time events.

For me, the most effective game music takes cues from pop music, featuring clear melodic and/or rhythmic hooks, a hummable tune, harmonic progressions that make the hairs on your arms stand on end and a sense of energy that drives you onwards, inspiring you to check out the game world ever further.

So with that in mind, do you know what games these tracks are from?

Controls that don’t handle like a Rover Metro circa 1998

I’ve brought this up on the podcast a good few times, but one thing that really gets my goat with a lot of modern games, particularly “blockbusters”, is how animation fluidity is prioritised over smooth, responsive control. I hated it back when Prince of Persia was a thing and I hate it even more now it’s happening in three dimensions.

One thing I like about Japanese-designed games and those from the West that follow Japanese design sensibilities, almost without exception? You push a direction and your character frigging goes that way. No beautifully rendered body-twisting animation. No walking around with the turning circle of a small piece of military hardware. Just push left, go left. Even Dark Souls, a Japanese series strongly inspired by a Western aesthetic, gets this right.

Shit, I’ve written myself into a corner with this quiz thing I’ve apparently got going on, haven’t I? Uh… can you name the game from these control schemes and prompts…?

  • “If you push the directional button while pushing the [CANCEL] button to run. (earlier marked X)”
  • L1: Assignment, R1: Travel, L3: Running toggle, [Touchpad]: Message logs
  • Square: Weak attack, Triangle: Heavy attack, X: Special attack, O: Quick dodge, R1: Summon Servan/Servan Burst
  • Square: Light attack, Triangle: Heavy attack, X: Jump, O: Action, R2: Evade, R1: Fire, L2: Lock-on, L1: Pod program

Whew, got away with that one.

Unconventional and interesting game structures

There’s still a commonly held assumption that “the JRPG” (as if it’s a single, coherent thing) follows the same formula that SNES and early PS1-era games did. Thing is, even back then there were wildly experimental games that didn’t do the commonly accepted “linear first half, gradually open up world map a location at a time, then allow complete freedom just before final dungeon” formula.

While there’s nothing wrong with that classic formula — it was used in so many games with good reason — I really enjoy how a lot of modern JRPGs experiment with format and structure to create something interesting and refreshing to play through.

You know what to do by now… which games work like this?

  • Hang out in town. Chat up girls and bridal carry them to your bedroom. Then either take aim for the 100th floor of the tower to “finish” the game through a linear series of dungeons and raids, or explore the seemingly unrelated optional area that pretty much quadruples the size of the whole game and has a completely freeform structure.
  • There’s this guy, right, and he’s totally the heir to a kingdom, so you should probably follow him through a series of short stories to see how his life unfolds. But there’s also this other dude who is also an orphan that becomes very wealthy, so you should probably also see what he’s up to. And maybe they might have something to do with each other.
  • The world is being consumed by darkness! (Or, in one version, light!) The only way to save it is to run away before it catches up with you, meaning you’ll have to constantly move forwards, hacking up monsters, helping people and maybe making friends with the final boss rather than killing them.
  • Play the game. Play the second half again. Play the second half again. Play the second half again. Whoops, now you have nothing to show for your efforts. Good job!

Games that end

In this age of “games as a service”, for a lot of publishers it’s not about getting you to buy Hot New Game every month or two. Now it’s all about getting you to buy Hot New Game and then keep pumping money into it on a regular basis for the next ten years. Or possibly just the next year, when Hot New Game II comes out and you’ll be expected to do it all over again, naturally with nothing you invested into Hot New Game carrying over to Hot New Game II..

JRPGs, though? They end. And how! After 20, 40, 80, 100 hours… you’ll reach some sort of earth-shattering conclusion in most cases, and the whole thing will come to an actual climax and resolution. Those characters you’ve come to know and love in this setting that feels like a second home — they’ll be fighting for their lives in a battle that tests your understanding of the game’s core systems, accompanied by a stirring and dramatic soundtrack. Also something about controls and unconventional structures.

And when you’re done, you’re done. Of course, in many cases you can play it all over again with a New Game Plus mode, or perhaps there’s postgame content to explore… but there’s an actual ending, allowing you to free yourself from the game and do something else. Assuming you want to, of course.

So for today’s last question, then… can you name the game from the finale?

  • Atari is really frigging mad that people have forgotten about her, so you better beat some sense into her before things get really out of hand.
  • The volcano is manifesting, so you better go beat it up. Also there’s this ghost thing that you should probably also go and beat up. And a tree that needs a good kicking, too. And your friend could do with being put back to the correct age. Did you remember to save up your money? Or perhaps you could just go to bed and forget all about this malarkey, because all of it is completely optional.
  • Your girlfriend had a bit too much meat, so you should probably try and calm her down a bit. I hear Liszt helps.
  • One of the titular characters is going to end up dead whatever you do. The question is, will that death carry any meaning?

How did you do? If you want to check your answers, click here and crack the fiendish code…


Thanks for reading; I hope you enjoyed this article. I’ve been writing about games in one form or another since the days of the old Atari computers, with work published in Page 6/New Atari User, PC Zone, the UK Official Nintendo Magazine, GamePro, IGN, USgamer, Glixel and more over the years, and I love what I do.

If you’d like to support the site and my work on it, please consider becoming a Patron — click here or on the button below to find out more about how to do so. From just $1 a month, you can get access to daily personal blog updates and exclusive members’ wallpapers featuring the MoeGamer mascots.

If you want to show one-off support, you can also buy me a coffee using Ko-Fi. Click here or on the button below to find out more.

Buy Me a Coffee at ko-fi.com

3 thoughts on “Seven Arbitrarily Chosen Things You’re Missing Out On If You’ve Been Operating Under the Mistaken Belief that JRPGs are “Dead””

  1. I do like that these sorts of games usually have a clear story (not a tacked on story mode) and the endings are usually pretty epic, if you make it that far. It is a definite advantage to the genre over so many other games.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. I can’t give this enough amens. JRPGs might have gone a little underground in the West after the PSX/N64 era, but artistically they’ve been doing just fine, thank you. People who think the genre went stagnant are like people who say modern music sucks. If you only look at the surface, it might seem that way, but if you dig just a little bit you’ll see what you were missing out on the whole time.

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.